Hegel

CONTENTS

ix

Translators’ Introduction

NEGATIVITY. A CONFRONTATION WITH HEGEL APPROACHED FROM NEGATIVITY (1938–39, 1941)


3

I. Negativity. Nothing—abyss—beyng

3

1. On Hegel

6

(1) Clarification of a concern regarding the value of such a confrontation

8

(2) Specification of the conceptual language that comes into play in the confrontation

9

(3) Preliminary characterization of the standpoint and principle of Hegel’s philosophy

10

2. At a glance

12

3. Becoming

13

4. Negativity and the “noting”

14

5. Negativity and being- other [Anderssein]

14

6. Negativity and otherness [Andersheit]

15

7. Negativity—difference of consciousness—subject-object relationship and essence of truth

15

8. Hegel’s concept of being

17

9. Hegel’s absolute negativity interrogated directly about its “origin”

17

10. Hegel’s negativity

19

11. Review

20

12. Negativity

22

13. The differentiation (separation)

22

14. The negative

22

15. Being and the nothing

23

16. Hegel’s concept of “being” in the narrow sense (“horizon” and “guiding thread”)

24

17. The “standpoint” of Hegelian philosophy is the standpoint of “absolute idealism”

25

18. The (thoughtful) pre-suppositions of Hegelian thinking

26

19. The pre-suppositions of Hegelian thinking of being in the narrow and broad sense

27

20. Review

27

21. The historical confrontation and the regress to “presuppositions”


29

II. The realm of inquiry of negativity

29

1. On the conceptual language

29

2. Negativity

32

3. Review


34

III. The differentiation of being and beings

34

1. Differentiation as de-cision

34

2. The differentiation of being and beings


36

IV. Clearing—Abyss—Nothing

36

1. The clearing (beyng)

37

2. Being: the a-byss

37

3. Beyng and nothing

38

4. A-byss and nothing and no

38

5. Beyng and nothing

39

6. “Negativity”

39

7. The nothing


40

V. Hegel

40

1. Essential considerations concerning the conceptual language

41

2. Hegel

41

3. “Becoming”

42

4. The pure thinking of thinking

42

5. “The higher standpoint”

43

6. Hegel’s “impact”

44

7. Metaphysics

44

8. On Hegel

45

9. “The logical beginning” (“pure being”)


46

Appendix

46

Supplement to the title page

46

Supplement to I, section 1 (p.3)

ELUCIDATION OF THE “INTRODUCTION” TO HEGEL'S “PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRIT” (1942)


51

Preliminary consideration. On the varied role and position of the Phenomenology of Spirit within Hegel’s metaphysics

62

I. The grounding of the enactment of the presentation of appearing knowledge (paragraphs 1–4 of the “Introduction”)

66

II. The self- presentation of appearing knowledge as the course into the truth of its own essence (paragraphs 5–8 of the “Introduction”)

71

III. The criterion of the examination and the essence of the examination in the course of appearing knowledge (paragraphs 9–13 of the “Introduction”)

71

1. The criterion- forming consciousness and the dialectical movement of the examination

74

2. Review of the previous discussion (I–III)

78

3. The experience [Er-fahren] of consciousness

82

IV. The essence of the experience of consciousness and its presentation (paragraphs 14–15 of the “Introduction”)

82

1. Hegel’s “ontological” concept of experience

101

2. Guiding propositions to Hegel’s concept of experience

104

V. Absolute metaphysics (sketches for paragraph 16 of the “Introduction”)

104

1. Essential considerations. Objectness and “science”

104

2. At a glance 1

105

3. The ray of the absolute. At a glance 2

105

4. The phenomenology of spirit

106

5. The movement

106

6. The by-play [Bei-her-spielen]

107

7. The examination

107

8. The onto-theological character

107

9. The reversal

108

10. The Germans and metaphysics

108

11. The absolute and man

108

12. Reflection—counter push—reversal

109

13. Projection and reversal

109

14. Experiences as transcendental experiences

110

15. The metaphysics of Schelling and Hegel

110

16. “Phenomenology” and absoluteness

110

17. Confrontation with Hegel

111

18. Hegel (Conclusion)


112

Appendix. Supplements to I–IV (paragraphs 1–15 of the “Introduction”)

112

1. Dialectic

112

2. Our contribution [Zu-tat]

112

3. The reversal—properly speaking four essential moments

112

4. The experience as the essential midpoint of consciousness


115

Editor’s Afterword

119

Translators’ Notes

123

German-English Glossary

135

English-German Glossary




On Inception (GA 70) [GA App]

Ereignis